Nanaimo Bars: A Delicious Canadian Dessert - Old American Recipes (2024)

Sharing is caring!

Nanaimo Bars, where have you been all my life? How, in my coast-to-coast travels throughout Canada—including Nanaimo itself (where you, Dear Readers, must visit because it’s totally gorge), did I miss your creamy goodness? The road to find you has been long, with many a winding turn, but now that I’m here, I shall make up for lost time and sing your praises.

The road to Nanaimo (bars) went like this: In myfirst postfor #CreativeCookieExchange, I whinged about the loss of my beloved Sunshine Biscuit Cookies. Karen, of the lovely blogKaren’s Kitchen Stories(a fave of mine), commented how SHE missed Sunshine’s Custard Cups. I’d never heard of them so I Googled. Google turned up nothing on said cookies but did lead me to a plethora of other custardy cookies. Custardy cookies that are made withBird’s Custard Powder. Not being one to let a new ingredient pass me by, one short visit to Amazon and two days later, Bird’s Custard Powder was delivered to Chez Dough. I chose a popular custardy cookie recipe (which shall remain nameless just in case it was ME and not the recipe) for my first attempt and it was awful beyond words, thus wasting a full cup of the precious powder. My bad. Not to be bested, I Googled again, looked a little deeper and Nanaimo bars came up time and time again. If nothing else, I figured such a beautiful city couldn’t possibly produce a bad cookie so I took a chance. I’m not sorry. Had I not just started back on Weight Watchers (nice timing, eh?), I’m sure I would have snarfed down the entire batch, possibly without taking a breath.

So what IS a Nanaimo Bar anyway? At its roots a Nanaimo bar is a layered bar cookie with a cookie-crumb bottom layer (most often made with graham crackers, coconut, cocoa and almonds), a creamy custardy middle layer and a chocolate top layer.Wikipedia(I know, I know, but even the official website for the city of Nanaimo links to it) traces the origins of the Nanaimo bar to the Modern Cafe in Nanaimo and its first appearance in print back to 1953. (Let us note here that New York has also laid claim to this delectable treat but we New Yorkers tend to do that with everything. New Yorkers are like Star Trek’s Mr. Chekov in that. No matter what it was, he’d always say “You know, that was inwented in Russia.” But I’m going with Canada on this one.) There are countless variations on the theme, so in 1986, the city of Nanaimo held a contest to determine theUltimate Nanaimo Bar. And out of nearly 100 recipes, they chose this one, baked by Joyce Hardcastle. Even I, a non-lover of chocolate and a hater of nuts, have to admit that this is cookie perfection. Not too sweet (in spite of what you’d think looking at the ingredients). Not too rich. Just right. Joyce, you done good.

Now since this is essentially a no-bake cookie (there’s just a bit of stove-top cooking involved), I thought I’d be cheating if I didn’t actually bake something for a post for a baking group, so I did bake the graham crackers that ended up as crumbs (I used the wonderful grahams from Nancy Silverton’sPastries From the La Brea Bakery). You certainly wouldn’t be wimping out, though, if you used store-bought. In fact, for the instant-gratification junkies among us, it’s probably the better way to go since this is a very quick and easy recipe and you’ll be miffling* Nanaimo bars in no time. Seriously—and I know bloggers say this all the damned time—this really could be the Best. Cookie. Ever.

So I thank you, Joyce. I thank you, Nanaimo. And I thank you, Canada. Poutine AND Nanaimo bars? Is Canada a great country or what?

*It’s a family word—and we’ve all got ‘em—that basically means to inhale your food. In my family we miffle a LOT.

Sharing is caring!